RANDAL:Shaheen Shaw comentating.

Smiley, massive ego and all, streets ahead of Shaheen.

imo, Shaheen is a top drawer studio presenter, I see no reason why he would not also excel presenting at the track but he is a definitely NOT a commentator.

catschop

what has his beard got to do with anything

Chop that thing maybe its getting in the way of some of his words...

Grunbergers "refreshingly different" comment must go down as the quote of the week.

LB and his minimum 4 other ABC forum alias's will be delighted.

Chris LOL!

G-Man.......you suck!!!!!

thanks man

Refreshingly different - I stick by it.

Chris, variety is surely the spice of life and nobody has yet written the ''Commentator's Bible'' to say that thy shall do this or that...maybe the way he commentates irks some guys but you gotta admit he is different - refreshingly so at times during a boring afternoon?

He is not the worst on the planet either by a long shot - the Chariot Racing oke from Sweden and the Zimbo are shocking. Then Dampie Schoeman in PE regularly gets things wrong - check his 35 second delay between third and fourth spot in the one PE race on Friday

Longbeard also ranks only second to Troubleshooter as being the most battered ram on this show. Let's live and let live and allow every man the opportunity to earn an honest living.....

To put it short and sweet cos im too lazy to type a whole arguement, he sucks!

Grun - Note from my comments I praise Longbeards presentational skills, I am genuinely a huge fan, this is his strength. He battled admirably with a difficult task with France yesterday afternoon and always does a sound job with local racing.

His commentating, however green he may be, is not in the same league.

Why play people out of position....? It's akin to playing Samuel Eto in goal, Oz Durant on the wing or having Graeme Smith open the bowling...!!!

well said chris